Bayonetta has a horrible story and character set compared to DMC. Sure, its a chick you strips for attacks, but w/e. That's what the internet is for. Plus, why is there Rings? Is she Sonic? No. The best game in this topic is GTA4. Due to tons of replay, great enviroment and some epic online multiplayer.
I'll say GTA 4, it even has two more stories to play after you have completed GTA 4 itself. The ballad of tony and the damned and the cursed both on a disc. I play most Rpgs but I think Army of Two has excellent graphics, only it's a bit short, it's quite fun. Resident Evil 5 is a must I think and uh Dante's Inferno?
GTA IV- Great gameplay/story Great Xbox LIVE Great just to muck around and kill people And if you get bored you can buy The Ballard of gay Tony/ Lost and Damned on the disc or buy them from Xbox LIVE. Great game