What would be the worst kind of torture for the avatar above?

Forsooth!

Read the rules...

Tortures you in the nicest way and then ties you by your tongue and lets you stand on a stool that you can juuuuust reach with your tippy toes.

 

Slit your throat open

 

I don't have a throat!

Rips your nails off!

 

Oh.... That doesn't sound good!

Cut your black looking wings thats black and red thing on your back

 

Nope

I cut your ears off then sonic boom them!

 

Th... F?ck

 

Taking the roms away.

Wait a minute...

 

Removal of your beak!

 

Taking that knife out.

 

Taking the cat away.

 

Having her species devolve into sea-dwelling creatures again.

 

Having Layton ignore him.

 

being trapped alone in a room with me.
he'd die of longing or something

 

A girl that dumps him.
Or being kicked by the Big Show, Kane, John Cena, Rey Mysterio and the Undertaker.

 

Being left alone in the desert...without JAK!

 

No strange animal which I can't tell what it is to poke.

 

Lettting the creeper have the unicorn

 

The girl on the right watching the guy being flayed alive! :3

 

Making him 3D

 

Break ups