1. This forum is in read-only mode.

Star Wars or Star Trek?

Discussion in 'Debates' started by k9112009, Jun 30, 2009.

  1. frebels

    frebels Well-Known Member

    stargate an option?
     
  2. Buppazugan

    Buppazugan Well-Known Member

    Stargate wins out of both of them :p

    But as this is Star Wars vs Star Trek, i will go with Star Wars. Star Trek is just moral dilema after moral dilema, and just too care-bearey (if that's even a word...)
     
  3. cuccio123

    cuccio123 Well-Known Member

    Well.
    Let's look at the most historic fight scenes.
    Yeah, its hard to tell what's better.
     
  4. redoperator

    redoperator Well-Known Member

  5. timmy1991

    timmy1991 Well-Known Member

    I grew up watching the Star Wars movies, and when I tried to watch Star Trek, I just kept comparing Wookies to Klingons, C3-P0 to Data, and Yoda to Spock... Sorry, I just couldn't watch it...
     
  6. stirgo1212

    stirgo1212 Well-Known Member

    Never seen star trek. But from what i hear its pretty good.
    Ive seen the 1st star wars but it wasent all that good. prefer action movies like james bond/ crank
     
  7. timmy1991

    timmy1991 Well-Known Member

    By first star wars, do you mean Episode I or Episode IV... since IV came out almost 20+ years before I
     
  8. ADGS231

    ADGS231 Well-Known Member

    Okey the point is that Star Wars is best than Star Trek
     
  9. damanali

    damanali Well-Known Member

    By just seeing this picture, i go with Star wars better than star trek.

    WTF, is that guy blowing at the storm troopers? and is that a remote control the girl is pressing? Those are clones, not droids so the remote control will not work. lol
     
  10. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    It's not a remote control, its a tricorder. It will tell her what the enemies are, what they're made of and what their weaknesses are.
     
  11. theunderling

    theunderling Well-Known Member


    Star Trek - the original 3 series.
     
  12. damanali

    damanali Well-Known Member

    In a galactic battle, and even in ground warfare, the Star War series in my opinion has more cooler weaponry and war ships/transports than Star Trek.
     
  13. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    you very rarely see a full scale battle in star trek. Try the dominion wars in DS:9 or Voyager: endgame to see a proper space battle fleet in the star trek universe.
     
  14. damanali

    damanali Well-Known Member

    After seeing pictures of dominion wars and Voyager endgame... My view has been more clearer that Star Wars kicks ass.

    George Lucas has his money spent well on Star Wars. But it intrigue me to watch Star Trek and all its movies.
     
  15. redoperator

    redoperator Well-Known Member

    star wars is losing it's luster
     
  16. markswan

    markswan Well-Known Member

    I think Star Wars lost "it's luster" (lustre?) with The Return of the Jedi; it completely disapeared with The Phantom Menace (although i was too young to realise these things upon original viewing, i actually quite liked TPM when i was 8-9 or however old i was; but whatever, most kids are stupid so i don't feel so bad about that (childish lack of cynicism and enjoyment of flashy stuff that 'splodes FTW).
    POST
    MODIFY
    Picard era Startrek was thought provoking and way better than all the great Star Wars moments put together IMO
     
  17. redoperator

    redoperator Well-Known Member

    didn't they have a startrek vs starwars fanclip on youtube?
     
  18. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    probably hundreds.
     
  19. ultra

    ultra Guest

    when you watch star trek, it has this gulliver's travel feel to it. an exploration of space, an adventure to the unknown. but in star wars, you don't really get this type of vibe.

    i like star trek because it has a richer context of the adventures that they undergo.
     
  20. msg2009

    msg2009 Romulations sexiest member

    aw bollocks.
    my favourite films/series/animation/story of all time has just been ruined!
    cheers george :(
    http://uk.tv.yahoo.com/blog/article/415394/