This ^ I've finished Red Dead Redemption; loved it. Nothing better than tying a damnsel to the tracks and waiting for a train to come.. A-Anyway, Game was awesome, and GTAIV with cowboys is a bit of a .. er. Word. Um. The similarities are obvious; but the cowboy theme, extensive gameplay and all the little touches; like hookers getting stabbed in the streets, random kidnappings, and an achievement for squishing a lady with a train, gives it a big golden star. However, I found this unnerving after a few hours in; staring at the main character (John Marston?) made me see Niko Bellic O_O Seriously.