1. This forum is in read-only mode.

Anime Reviews [Suggestion]

Discussion in 'Anime, Manga & Cartoons' started by crazytuna, Jul 6, 2009.

  1. tehuber1337

    tehuber1337 Well-Known Member

    I suppose I could write up some reviews, if need be, but as I said before, perhaps there should just be a single thread for it all. We could either have a special "team" of reviewers (like ANN), or enforce review standards as in the existing reviews board. If we have one per post, then the first post in the thread could be organised with links to each one, like a table of contents. This would solve the "problem" of creating an entire new board. On the other hand, one or more mods may be required to keep the thread nice and clean.
     
  2. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    Well I just finished a review and I hope it's good, cause it's my first one ever
    now should I make a new thread for it?
     
  3. forte_amirul

    forte_amirul Well-Known Member

    Let me start with Kamen Rider.;D

    So,which KR?
     
  4. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    Ok well I'm gonna start a new thread for all reviews
    or somebody should do it?

    I think every review should at least have animation. characters and sound as review criterias
     
  5. tehuber1337

    tehuber1337 Well-Known Member

    May as well stick with AniDB's review categories: animation, sound, story, character, value, enjoyment. I don't quite see the "worth" in the "value" category, though (c wut i did thar?).
     
  6. meganova

    meganova Well-Known Member

    I hope the mods can make a new section for it.
     
  7. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    I think enjoyment can be added to that, but the enjoyment part can be added in the Overall section at the end, where you usually conclude and add your opinion, thus the enjoyment

    and by story do you mean story development or story-telling?
    or maybe both?
     
  8. forte_amirul

    forte_amirul Well-Known Member

    Hmm,I need a review point.What shall I put?

    For Sentai,

    -Story
    -Summary
    -Character (I don't know about his)
    -Sound Effects & e.t.c
    -Hmm,need more..
     
  9. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    You actually don't need to put that much points in a review...
     
  10. meganova

    meganova Well-Known Member

    Just put the related one.
    Genre is a must of course.
     
  11. forte_amirul

    forte_amirul Well-Known Member

    Lol,anyway.

    I have made about storyline,summary.Then,what's next?
     
  12. tehuber1337

    tehuber1337 Well-Known Member

    Both.
     
  13. meganova

    meganova Well-Known Member

    I didn't know that huber is a former mods.. :)
     
  14. forte_amirul

    forte_amirul Well-Known Member

    Come on,Sentai is different.

    Okay,I think we should put these for the Sentai review.

    -Storyline
    -Character
    -Sound Effects & e.t.c
    -

    Ugh,I have no idea.
     
  15. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    anyway, I think you're going to be the only one to do a review on a sentai
     
  16. tehuber1337

    tehuber1337 Well-Known Member

    Former mods?

    For sentai, the animation category is the only redundant one (excluding the already mentioned value category). It could still be replaced with "visuals" or "camerawork" or something, though.
     
  17. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    tehuber do you used to make reviews?
    cause I want to see a good review, to make mine better, but I dont know which one are good or not
     
  18. tehuber1337

    tehuber1337 Well-Known Member

    I've reviewed games and such before, but not anime. I usually just read reviews, rather than write them. I guess I could give it a whirl, but I'll be kinda busy for the next couple of weeks.
     
  19. crazytuna

    crazytuna Well-Known Member

    nah it's fine, if your busy, dont neglect work for something as trivial >_<