1. This forum is in read-only mode.

[X360] Fallout 3 - 9NineBreaker9

Discussion in 'Game Reviews' started by 9NineBreaker9, Dec 16, 2008.

  1. 9NineBreaker9

    9NineBreaker9 Well-Known Member

    WARNING: Screenshots may include high amounts of blood and gore, but, as this is indeed a very mature game (rated 'M' or your country's equivalent), it's entirely expected to see some exploding heads. But a nice heads up, anyways.

    Fallout 3 | Xbox 360

    [​IMG]

    Developer(s): Bethesda Game Studios
    Publisher(s): Bethesda Softworks, ZeniMax Media
    Genre: Action RPG

    There are few things scarier than the thought of complete and all-out nuclear warfare - the use of mankind's most devastating and gruesome weapon to completely and utterly wipe out an entire civilization from the face of the Earth, while, at the same time, rendering the land struck dead for hundreds of years to come is a thought that can keep you up at night. There was once a time where the question of where you would be when the bombs fell was a common inquiry by most of the people... just thank goodness that something like that never happened. But, if it did, there is one place where you would want to be, and that's in a Vault-Tec hideout - safe from the fallout, safe from the bombs, safe from the destruction, you will lie peacefully... but are things really all that simple, all that... safe?

    You are born into the blazing light; a newborn child in a world where florescent lights are the only brightness you will ever know, and your cradle doubles as your coffin. You are given a name, your future being projected upon a screen for you to alter, and your childhood soon follows - you learn to walk, learn to talk, learn to frolic, and learn to kill. But as your less than idyllic childhood comes to a close as your father, the only parent you had and the only person you could ever trust, leaves you in a panic. You must now leave your only home and venture into a world known simply as the Wasteland, the barrens outside of the capital wasteland that was once a 1950's Washington D.C.

    The introduction of Fallout 3 is hands-down the best starting point for a game, starting quite literally with your conception and blending together the key steps of your character creation directly into your brief childhood. It's this and other elements of the wonderfully wasted D.C. that make this game completely immersive, should you let yourself be drawn away by it. While some things can pull you directly out of the experience, the best thing in Fallout 3 is that you can let yourself become but a lone person in a land hardly befitting life.

    [​IMG]
    Serene for its destruction, annoying for its recycled nature - the rose that is Fallout 3 is not without its thorns.

    And what a beautiful wasteland you have to be alone in. Your first glimpse of the desolate skyline is a truly memorable one, with the ravaged Washington Monument striking out it's place in the sky against destroyed buildings and lifeless country, but for those who have been to the city itself, it's strikingly realistic - at one point, I was traveling through the subway and to literally stop and just look around, as it felt as if I were actually back in the capital city, save for the crowds and the liveliness of it. The entire world is picturesque for its dystopian destruction, making the visual blemishes that do exist - poor draw distance, animation that ranges from bad to laugh-inducing, oftentimes horrific level design, and some notably bad textures - pale in comparison to both the striking realism of the city and the overall brilliant artistic design; seeing random posters for Sugar Bombs and the ever-present Vault Boy is sure to brighten your depressing ruins.

    The music score follows suit, for the most part, in setting up a completely epic scenario for you to blow up some fools in. Most of the tracks are entirely subtle, simply blending in to the wind as you walk across the Wasteland, or combining with the echoes, drips, and hidden voices of various dungeons to create a great atmosphere that is akin to Bioshock. However, it's the radio stations that really take the cake in this world - from the constant preaching and patriotic music of the Enclave to the wonderful 40's and 50's music from Galaxy News Radio, the radio stations are really well done, even when the static cuts into your enjoyment as you move further away from the signal (which is actually very cool). Sound effects are, well, there - nothing too amazing worth noting. Voice acting is well done, too, but the only outstanding performances from these lie in those who can bring the gritty script to life, meaning very few people - your father is just about the best performance in the game, but you'll have to get used to recycled voices throughout the game.

    Coming back once again to your birth, your character creation is certainly an involved process with a number of different scores coming together to form your character. You start with your SPECIAL scores, points that go into your main character attributes, such as Strength, Intelligence, or Charisma. One of the more interesting things with this system is that you can detract points from the average, allowing you to pull out points from, say, Luck, and pool them into Perception or Endurance, enabling you to create detailed character concepts, but thanks to some great balance on the developer's part, it's next to impossible to completely screw your character.

    Beyond this you have a number of different skill values, ranging from Small Guns (ironically including assault rifles and shotguns), Lockpicking, Barter, and Repair - each one has its own use, and specializing in these can pull out some great benefits later on. While some skills may seem rather useless, when used in combination with others, they really do shine; and thanks again to great balance, you can specialize in most anything and still come out well, save for melee and unarmed skills, which pale in comparison to any and every firearm. Each level allows you to increase these skills as you see fit, and also gives you a point to place into a Perk, a unique buff added to your character, such as increased carrying capacity, the ability to make foes explode, or increased stats in certain situations. With these, you can make a wide variety of characters, but the depth is thankfully just shallow enough to allow anyone jumping in an understanding of what exactly everything does, making it, again, next to impossible to completely screw a character over.

    All of these points and scores ultimately boil down to one thing - combat. The fights of Fallout 3 are definitely pretty fun, save for some major problems.

    [​IMG]
    VATS - melding real time and turn-based combat into one rather unfortunate mutation, not quite unlike this sterile, asexual mutant.

    Rather straightforward, you kill people dead in combat, but the variety of ways to do this is very entertaining and tie back into your skills - putting points into Big Guns make Miniguns devastating, while Energy Guns are useful only if you put points into the Energy Weapons skill. Unfortunately, weapons outside of the Small Guns category are notably hard to come by, either through the actual weapon or the ammo needed to use it, so their use is somewhat limited to the endgame, where guns like the Flamer have enough users to keep one in good condition and supplied with enough ammo. While this can be overcome somewhat, it still remains a notable issue when you want to specialize in something other than Small Guns.

    A player can choose to not only shoot up fools in real time, but also to slow things down with the VATS system, which allows you to spend some Action Points (in a nod to previous Fallout games) to slow down time, pause the game, target certain limbs, and let the destruction rain. However, these come down to simple rolls of the dice, so an otherwise accurate shot might be deemed impossible by VATS, but, at close range or with certain weapons, the system is a godsend, allowing you to maul people with ease... quite literally in fact, as killed enemies oftentimes explode into a flurry of limbs. While entertaining for a while, it does eventually get old to see heads flying in a torrent of blood and other appendages when you just want to get back into the flow. Because of the gratuitous violence, combat starts out as gritty and desperate, firing wildly to bring down irradiated freaks and raiders alike, but certain points can seem somewhat overdone, and not in a particularly good way. VATS ultimately becomes a bane for those used to a standard FPS experience, a nuance for typical players, and otherwise just another way to kill people, coming down to a combat system that feels awkwardly imprecise, trying to cater to too many people and not really succeeding either in real time, thanks to some shoddy camera work and unfriendly aiming mechanics, or in a mechanical, semi-real-time mode, either, as it is limited to your supply of Action Points and your ability to stomach the overly D&D dice-rolling experience and the exceedingly violent explosions.

    One interesting note - it's particularly hard for the controls to ever be an issue, but Fallout 3 certainly manages to break that mold by creating some seriously messed up control schemes. Combat constantly feels clunky and fidgeting through menus, locations, stances and views is a royal pain. It all comes down to a very annoying experience, especially in the heat of battle when you're trying to heal, switch back to first person, stop crouching, pull out your gun and turn off your light (seriously, holding buttons for an action is God-awful) - all tasks that are not made entirely easy.

    Outside of combat, there still remain a number of things to keep you busy. You can use Lockpicking to open up otherwise sealed doors, Science to control machinery to your advantage, Medicine to heal yourself up... or to get high, Repair to keep your weapons in tip-top shape (as they degrade with use, a wholly realistic situation, albeit somewhat annoying at times), and Barter and Speech to work people over to your advantage. Specializing in some of these abilities will open up new paths, both literally and indirectly, by offering up new conversation paths or giving you access to otherwise blocked off areas...

    [​IMG]
    Simply exploring the Wasteland remains one of the most entertaining elements of the game, both fascinating and depressing at the same time.

    ... Which leads to the element of exploration. Post-Apocalyptia is an amazing place to venture forth into, especially as all the locations in the world remain a mystery until you go there. As soon as the game really starts, you can head in the direction opposite of the main quest and just see where the game takes you - perhaps it’s into a desolate metro station, a torn-up city, a raider camp, or some place truly surprising. Just wondering around is one of the best things to do, even as the landscapes begin to blend together - while shockingly destroyed to start off with, it gets somewhat old to look at rock outcrop and collapsed building time and time again... which, while keeping in the realism, still means that the environments are recycled over time and space, but still do keep in surprisingly well with the actual geography of the area.

    In exploring the Wasteland, you'll come by a number of quests for you to complete, doled out by townsfolk, fake governments, hopeless regimes and out-of-place groups. While the number of quests is sometimes minimal, the immense depth within each one and the number of paths that you can take (and the ways to complete them) is something to be admired - for each straightforward, plain solution, there are just as many devious, subtle, and fulfilling ways to save or ruin someone's life. Each mission also bears with it a distinct moral choice, oftentimes making you pause and consider the consequences should you sell someone out, save a person, or damn an entire town to a nuclear holocaust.

    Ultimately, Fallout's greatest component is a certain element of immersion - from the beginning of the game to simply wandering about; it's easy to get lost in the sheer ambiance of it all. At times, I've been drawn in entirely to the world, simply loving walking around town, exploring a metro station, and fighting for my life. However, for each time the game brings you in, it decides to kick you out just as fast - leveling occurs the exact instant you are out of combat; glitches and game crashes detract from the experience when you're forced to restart the system; conversations with the NPCs generally feel static and oftentimes forced recycled voices, locations and enemies get old after the fifth time; random halts and otherwise poorly implemented events are a real pain - these issues range from frequent to rare encounters, but they are notable for completely ruining the experience quickly and entirely.

    At the end of the day, Fallout 3 is certainly a step away from the previous Fallout games, but similarly a step in a new, mushroom-cloud-shaped direction - between the fantastic atmosphere, great immersion, gritty and adrenaline-filled combat and a fantastic blend of exploration and detail-oriented quests make for a well done game that is marred with constant problems, bugs, glitches and other issues, including controls, breaks in the immersion, a somewhat clunky combat experience and recycled... everything (but in a post-nuclear scenario, perhaps it's all too realistic to have everything recycled). Perhaps you can still stomach all the rads from drinking this potion, you'll come to enjoy the sweetness of it all - just be prepared for the nasty side effects.

    [​IMG]
    Get used to this. Get used to seeing a LOT of this. Entirely too much of this, really.

    Presentation, 8/10: Aesthetically, the menu and other apsects of the presentation are astounding - in keeping with the 50's theme, everything feels just as it should, should things be in the future but stuck in the past and in a complete hell hole. However, actually navigating this mess leaves something to be desired.
    Graphics, 8/10: Again, the overall theme of the game is a constant blessing, with environments being, from an artistic standpoint, absolutely beautiful and well crafted. However, the constant recycling of environments, the bland nature of these environments (gray, wreaked, and rocky), and the oftentimes hilariously bad animation detract from an otherwise drop-dead gorgeous game.
    Sound, 8/10: Honestly, my favorite part of the game, if only for Galaxy News Radio and it's constant 40's and 50's upbeat jazz and otherwise retro music - other than this, the sound design makes for a hauntingly epic, completely immersive experience while playing the game, but that's attributed to environmental effects, not amazing scores. Sound effects are good enough, and voice acting is sufficient.
    Gameplay, 7/10: At first glance, the combat is awesomely violent and well done, but once you actually get your hands on the controller, it starts to fall apart with some seriously funky controls and an otherwise clunky combat system, VATS included. Character creation, however, is wholly in-depth, but shallow enough to let anyone play, and exploring the Wasteland is simply awesome, especially if you can look at the Mall or the metro stations and compare that to the real deal.
    Lasting Appeal, 8/10: Due to the sheer depth of some of the quests, you'll have to replay them time and time again to see all of the outcomes, dialogue paths and events that occur with the evil or good routes. While this can't be said of the main quest (largely a tale of catch-up), most of the side quests are involving endeavors.

    Total Score, 39/50: Fallout 3 is by no means a bad game, but it strays so often and so severely from the mutated path of perfection that the fallacies simply must be called out as detracting from the whole game experience. Yes, it boils down to being Oblivion in the future with guns, but that's not really all that bad of a thing, especially when the formula for an open-ended game is so well done and believable (and I, for your information, believe that Oblivion can die in a pyre). However, the nuclear wasteland simply must be experience, disregarding the amount of bodily harm you will suffer for it - what doesn't kill you will just make you a deformed monstrosity.

    "How 'ya doin', Post-Apocalyptia!?"


    ~~~

    I've been having quite a bit of fun with this game. It was a decision between this and the critically acclaimed Left 4 Dead, but, even though I loved L4D, I still wanted to pick up an immersive RPG such as this, if only because that's my forte. I went in expecting a futuristic Oblivion, and that's exactly what I got (and I hated Oblivion, by the way), but this game seemed so much more... real to me. Like this could actually happen, like this world could actually exist. It feels so much more alive to me and so much more inspiring to see locations and buildings I've been to in real life to be completely wreaked - it's an awesome experience, and my favorite part of the game is just to dink around, aimlessly traveling the Wasteland and wondering where I might happen onto next.

    But, yeah. I got this with the new Castlevania game for the DS, Order of Ecclesia, and what I've played of it (I've been playing entirely too much Fallout for my own good, really - I think I'm getting irradiated or something), it's a nice game, but I'm a fan of the more recent Castlevania titles (Symphony of the Night... meh), so that was a given.

    I'll be getting Left 4 Dead, don't you fret, but you'll have to wait 'till the new year, as I'm not getting anything for Christmas, save for a vacation to Mexico. And not the tourist Mexico, the parts of Mexico where the people are running away into different countries. Yeah, my parents decided to go for the "real" Mexican experience. Which is still ironic due to their booking a full bed-and-breakfast in a town with full tourist services. All well.

    I'll just have to shoot some zombie fools up in '09.

    (And sorry if the pictures are too big, or if I omitted something - finals just kicked up at school, so I can't devote too much time to games at the moment... although that has been an... ahem... work in progress... yeah)
     
  2. Cahos Rahne Veloza

    Cahos Rahne Veloza The Fart Awakens

    Another great review nine :D

    And that awesome headshot really made my day, loooove iiiit!
     
  3. dmac154

    dmac154 Well-Known Member

    A little harsh on the score there nine. But you are correct with the combat system being a bit whack, I hated it, even for the PC. Anyway good job putting this piece together.
     
  4. 9NineBreaker9

    9NineBreaker9 Well-Known Member

    Thanks for the input, y'all.

    This definitely isn't a bad game, but it certainly does come with a number of problems - if you can get around those, it's an excellent game whose quality can't be understated (at least within the aesthetic and design spheres), but the combat really is hard to get used to and full of problems.

    But I still enjoy the game, nonetheless. I started another profile and got back to the Tranquility Lane quest... that right thar... that was awesome, if a bit annoying. But still really trippy and well done.

    And I TOTALLY don't say "BOOM HEADSHOT" after every single VATS decapitation. Seriously. I so don't do that. *cough*
     
  5. fareyzd

    fareyzd New Member

    This game seems so brutal,but i like it much than Far Cry 2.
     
  6. jc_106

    jc_106 Well-Known Member

    Excellent review, Nine. I have this game for PC, and the combat can be annoying some times, indeed, but not that much. Also, I wouldn't expect green pastures in a post apocalyptic landscape, it's normal that all there is is gray, brown and black.

    On that note, I got a perk, something about more critical shots and... well, people literally exploding when there's a critical shot. I love that thing.
     
  7. grimsim1

    grimsim1 Well-Known Member

    I can't believe I missed this review. Harsh score man, but an otherwise excellent review. It is truly annoying when an enemy is right in front of your face and you blast a shotgun shell in his head, yet he doesn't die. Other than that I have had no complaints (slight lag when entering buildings, but that's probably a system error). Exploring the wasteland is so much fun. Can't wait until I replace my faulty graphics card and carry on playing this beautiful game.
     
  8. jc_106

    jc_106 Well-Known Member

    That's most probably due to loading, I have it too. Not severe, though.
     
  9. 9NineBreaker9

    9NineBreaker9 Well-Known Member

    I've noticed that there is a minor bit of slowdown on some areas (on the 360, at least), but what bugs me more is the game's tendency (again, on the 360) to randomly CRASH. You'll be walking and... BAM... dead stillness. Which, when you've been walking for an hour and haven't actually saved at any recent point is seriously aggravating - I've yet to return to it when almost an hour and a half's play time flew away with that.

    Granted, I should have been saving more, but there's nothing like a good game-halting glitch/bug/whatever the hell to piss you off.
     
  10. jc_106

    jc_106 Well-Known Member

    Mine never crashed, except when I wanted to exit the game from the game itself. I figured I have to go to the main menu first, and exit there. Pausing and exiting in the middle of the game crashes (on Vista at least).
     
  11. supersonicsparky

    supersonicsparky Well-Known Member

    Dang! This review is teh SH1T! mine is horrible :/
     
  12. jc_106

    jc_106 Well-Known Member

    I have also been thinking of that possibility, you never know when a nuclear war might knock at the door. :p

    But I'm being serious, I have found myself sleeping during classes thinking Fallout 3 could eventually become real. And it's not pretty.
     
  13. Phgsx

    Phgsx New Member

    using your rating system i would rate Fallout a 43/50 i think you may be a little too harsh when you rate games even with some of the most advanced gaming tech ever we cannot create a perfect game
     
  14. anandjones

    anandjones Well-Known Member

    Yeah I've got this now. I gotta say, it's pretty fucking awesome. Huge environment. Love killing people in their own homes, and slicing them up (with their arms and legs cut off of course). Also get annoyed at guys not getting killed instantly from a close range. And I have had the game freeze on me twice, once was during saving, and another was walking through Megaton.
     
  15. 9NineBreaker9

    9NineBreaker9 Well-Known Member

    I know, I've randomly thought "OMG FALLOUT 3!!!" at random points during our history class, especially when we spent a day looking at extremely dark art... and that again wasn't very entertaining thoughts =/

    I don't think I'm being "harsh", as the game still has a fairly good score and standing in my book. And I also am fully aware that perfection is something that cannot be ever obtained, which is why I have yet to give anything the standing of "perfect media". It aggrivates me to no end when anyone or anything gives a game a "perfect" score, as it's simply not possible for a game to be perfect, ESPECIALLY in something as personal as video game tastes.

    I've never been one for killing random doods, even on my "spawn of Satan" character - but I still do enjoy taking a nice bladed weapon and cutting up some fools every now and again >=D

    ... or that bullets are capable of cutting off limbs. Well, sometimes, yes, but I highly doubt that a singular bullet will cut off an entire leg, or that a person's eyeball can contain all of their armor and munitions... beyond this, the combat's... usually fun. I find myself getting somewhat bored one-shotting damn near everything on my 20 character, but only somewhat.
     
  16. nice review :),but i have to point this out :p its not 1950 washington but something like 2150 or so (when the bombs fell,please better me if im wrong),excellent review still,and are you getting l4d for xbox?oh and how's the expansion of fallout,you tried it yet?
     
  17. 9NineBreaker9

    9NineBreaker9 Well-Known Member

    You're correct - the bombs don't fall in the 1950's but rather in 2077, but the style of everything is a quintessential stylization of an 1950's America - see the Tranquility Lane quest line for a bit of a better example.

    I have purchased Left4Dead recently, and I've forgotten that I've yet to write something for it - maybe if I have to time, I'll get around to it...

    As for the Fallout expansions - the only I think I will get, if any of them, is the one that extends the main game and raises the level cap to 30 - I don't feel as though just a few hours of material justifies the cost, and buying things on Live is, for me, a complete and utter hassle.
     
  18. spazztrops

    spazztrops Member

    AWESOMEEEE!!!. screenshot 4 looks cool i like gore
     
  19. Ultimate-Sonic-3000

    Ultimate-Sonic-3000 Well-Known Member