1. This forum is in read-only mode.

people eatinr deep fried fish that still alive.

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by Apollooo, Nov 20, 2009.

  1. Apollooo

    Apollooo Well-Known Member

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BYPuLnAscA

    well, i dunno if that fish is really alive or just some nerve twitch when it was fried, but it's really cruel, if you just want to eat something just eat something just kill it instantly, not like this.

    how would PETA react if they see this??
     
  2. kamuikurou

    kamuikurou Well-Known Member

    well... I've even heard of a gourmet sashimi consisting of alive shrimp. :)
     
  3. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    I really wouldn't care two hoots about what peta think, the best thing they could do for animals would be throw themselves in front of an express train.
     
  4. Apollooo

    Apollooo Well-Known Member

    it's just nasty..i would prefer my food dead, and well done, and i heard fish feel pain too, or 'sense' more exactly... like clams, and lobster cooking alive, but this is just more cruel...
     
  5. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    it wont still be alive after deep frying.
     
  6. Apollooo

    Apollooo Well-Known Member

    if not it just would be nerves twitch, like you cut pig's head instantly (it's a culture from my country to cut pig's head, and tribute it to the spirits) the body is still running around a minute.
    maybe same thing happened to the fish too. they said it alive, but it might be just a "trick " to make fish look alive.
     
  7. Kage56

    Kage56 Well-Known Member

    to tell you the truth, i could honestly care less.
    animals do these things all the time(eating them live), and we kill the dam things after raising them(slaughter house).
    painless or not, killing is cruel.
    religious, traditional, sacrificial, survival, whatever excuse you have doesn't change that fact.

    i'm all for dead and fully cooked, but however people want to eat it is how they want to eat it as long as they're not pushing the damn thing in my face.
     
  8. Loonylion

    Loonylion Administrator Staff Member

    its not common for animals to eat other live animals. They generally kill the food first.
     
  9. Kage56

    Kage56 Well-Known Member

    some do eat them alive though...
     
  10. damanali

    damanali Well-Known Member

    An excellent clip! How do they do that? half of it is cooked while the other half is still alive.
    How can it be deep fried and it still alive? Just amazing...

    I feel sorry for the thing but i'm more curious on how it was done than being sorry...
     
  11. ace1o1

    ace1o1 Well-Known Member

    i've heard of that before......a friend of mine told me about a restaruant where they serve the fish while it's still alive............they cut out most of the organs in the belly of the fish and just leave the heart, lungs, brain, the essentials.....and they cook and serve them while the fish is still alive.

    i wouldn't be surprised if the fish in that video were still alive.

    i prefer to eat dead animals......not alive ones....but PETA isn't any concern to me...

    pretty much!
     
  12. MadmanNero

    MadmanNero Well-Known Member

    Same thing happens with chickens as well.
     
  13. Rysio

    Rysio Well-Known Member

    But when you cut off it's head, it doesn't feel pain anymore. Frying fish alive is just cruel, I'd like to do the same with those bastard cooks ...^-^
     
  14. Natewlie

    Natewlie A bag of tricks

    Fish apparently can't feel pain. They can show signs of discomfort, but they don't feel pain.

    I say apparently because this topic is still just a theory and still being debated about.
     
  15. MadmanNero

    MadmanNero Well-Known Member

    We can wait until they deep fry a live chicken then we all will have something to talk/raise hell about.
     
  16. MindFever

    MindFever Well-Known Member

    okay this is stupid... alive FRIED FISH ? hmm weird... its like 250 Celsius in the boiling oil,dammit! i hate you ... (lol,random word...dont take it seriously)
     
  17. Apollooo

    Apollooo Well-Known Member

    but still as i said we don't know that fish is really alive or just because immidiate frying and cutting makes nervous system twitch and make the mouth moves, just like you grilling prawns, after death if you grill it it's still moves becasue of the heat affecting theirs nervous system
     
  18. damanali

    damanali Well-Known Member

    what? nobody poked the eye while watching it? then its not that cruel...
     
  19. Apollooo

    Apollooo Well-Known Member

    now that's cruel... lol
     
  20. calvin_0

    calvin_0 Well-Known Member

    so people fried fish while they are still alive.... big deal.... back then i help my granma beheaded a chicken alive (that was the easy part, the feather part is hellish)..... in fact i kill alot of animal soon to be food when i was a kid.

    anyway I am a member of PETA myself, People Eat Tasty Animal.