Notice: Tulba is a man. Seriously. Developer: Atlus Publisher: Atlus Genre: Medical Simulation (Wiki says 'Visual Novel' as well, but that's kind of crap - you've failed me, Wikipedia) When people think of the Nintendo DS, there are quite a few things that come to mind, but one of those things is definitely not surgery. Well, thanks to the success of the first Under the Knife title on the DS, followed by the port, Second Opinion, as well as an original, oft mentioned title, New Blood, the surgery simulator is now a respected and almost entirely exclusive genre to Atlus. Now, several years after the release of the first title on the DS, the first actual sequel to the original, cult classic has been released in Under the Knife 2. It has been three years since the outbreak of GUILT, a scientifically created virus used by the terrorist organization Delphi in an attempt to rid the modern world of medicine, believing that doctor’s quest to heal those in need of assistance harms the evolution of the world by allowing the weak to survive. Derek Stiles began his work as an unsteady intern, but quickly became the pride of the medical community, and, alongside the star nurse, Angie Thomson, broke down Delphi and brought an end to the reign of GUILT across the world. Now, Derek is assisting in the small, war-torn African country of Cogistar, brining medical aid to the victims of internal struggle. It is not long, however, before several patients come in bearing very odd and frighteningly familiar conditions that bring Derek, Angie, and upcoming hopeful Adel Tulba, back to the United States – it appears that GUILT ridden patients are now bearing post-operation mutations, and that the shadows of a dead organization are moving in the darkness to bring back the former glory that is medical terrorism. Welcome to Cogistar, an African tastefully and surprisingly unrelated to terrorism - whoda thunk? While the plot is definitely not going to be winning awards, it follows the suit of the three other games in being very well written and holding together an otherwise odd and really quite far-fetched idea while keeping the interest of the player. There’s a bit of character evolution, some falling outs, as well as enough changes to familiar faces to keep things moving forward at a constant, steady pace; those who have played the previous installments in the series will be welcomed by familiar faces, though new players won’t be completely alienated by anything, either. Overall, it’s not particularly amazing, but just interesting enough to hold the game together, as well as flesh out operations. The bulk of the game is based in the operating rooms, however, and Atlus definitely does not disappoint this go around – in keeping things mostly the same, but by changing just a few keep elements, gameplay feels refreshing and original without feeling like more of the same or constant repetition, much like the first title was. Each patient comes in with some sort of problem, and it’s up to Derek and an assortment of assistance to rid the patient of that problem. Under the Knife was a constant GUILT frenzy, while New Blood barely use it’s unique and highly entertaining Stigma; the two extremes of the series. Thankfully, UtK2 finds a balance between these two in offering up some normal missions, such as the removal of aneurisms or skin grafts, as well as showcasing some old and new GUILT faces. Another interesting bit is that GUILT missions don’t always stay the same, adding an additional sprinkling of variety that keeps the gameplay from ever feeling too stale. I was unaware that you could sew a rib cage together... Once you’ve arrived to the body of the patient, you’re welcomed to a somewhat new interface – namely, the icons for each tool are much larger, and the heart rate bar, the sort of health meter that measures the current liveliness of your patient, seems more prominent without being overly obnoxious. The changes might take a little while getting used to, but everything seems to be for the better; selecting tools is a bit easier, and checking the current vitals, as well as the vital maximum, now marked on the bar, doesn’t feel too much like looking away from the patient entirely. From here, it’s a matter of what the symptoms are that determine how you go about the operation, but, for each task, the objectives are clear, precise, and, as far as theory goes, easy to perform. The literal difficulty in performing the operation remains one of Trauma Center’s defining traits – the game continues to be extremely difficult, oftentimes maddening, but the addition of an easier difficulty, as well as a far more difficult option, as well as the ability to feely change between difficulties during the game, makes sure that you can turn down the insanity if things become too hard, or turn it up if things are becoming too simple. The unlockable missions still remain on “Battletoads†difficulty. The use of each tool is simple, but their performances have changed just enough to be noticeably different, for the better and the worse. The Antibiotic gel now has a far shorter use period, meaning that you can’t hold down the stylus for as long before needing to reapply the miracle medication – a different, but not necessarily a setback. The drain still remains awkward, but now an auto-suction feature seems to have been put in place in that, just by pressing the tube, the material moves upwards, rather than you actually moving it up. However, that feature doesn’t work upon placement, meaning that you still need to motion to suck, very much unlike the Wii titles. It’s an improvement over the first DS title, but still annoying when in the fray. Thankfully, the syringe now completely plunges upon placement, meaning that you don’t have to drag it down – though an IV machine would still be nice… Noobs, expect to see that latter more often - this game is FRIGGEN' hard Operations are now better than ever thanks to a refreshing array of new obstacles, such as the removal of a gull bladder and a few new, interesting showings in the GUILT department. These changes, as well as a few new twists on old operations, will keep the veteran on their toes while keeping new players equally excited to see what trick is going to be taught to the old dog. The changes also ensure that once fairly difficult operations are now even more challenging, but, when playing religiously on the Normal difficulty, the overall challenge doesn’t stray too much from an overall difficult average, though a few missions do feature notable difficulty spikes, chiefly the skin graft operation and one horrific example of what happens when you have no stabilizers to boost the patients vitals. Beyond the operating room, a few new additions to the game have been added, primly a graphical update. The game’s visuals in the first were very well done, but a lot of the character portraits were almost comical and didn’t really fit the overall tone of the game. Now, the entire theme has been noticeably darkened and has been sprinkled with a bit more reality than the almost anime style of the first Under the Knife. Character portraits are now extremely detailed and very series, reflecting the tone of each passage well and more accurately. Surgical graphics retain the ‘realism’ shown in the Wii consoles, thankfully upholding the new theme fairly well, though the edges to a few items, notably the patient’s body, can be a bit harsh sometimes. This is to be expected out of the DS, however, so, as far as the entire game is concerned, the sporty new feel is upholded well on the puny DS hardware. Another notable feature is the soundtrack – the first game was surprising for its excellent music offering, as well as the two Wii titles, but this Trauma Center especially features very well done music. There are several tracks that fit the mood down to the last pixel, pushing the realism and theme of the case to the most immersive yet, but the out-of-operation sound list appears to be disappointingly barren, offering up a scant selection of tunes when you’re not cutting someone up. Granted, each of these songs is great, but their use for some situations feels a bit canned and unfitting. Trauma Center: Because who hasn't wanted to laser people's internal organs? On a more hilarious note are the wide amount of voice clips for almost every featured character. These are impressive from a designers point of view, being of a high sound quality and quantity, but all of these bytes become extremely awkward, odd, and even unintentionally funny, as they are very over dramatic and mismatched to both the dialogue, tone and implications, even going so far as to say the exact opposite of what the text of the character is saying, chief among which is when Derek’s voice protests Angie’s text: “You’re a doctor!†– “I… I…â€ÂÂ, as the text states. However… “You’re a doctor!†– “I DISAGREE!†sounds the voice clip. Yeah, did anyone actually notice that, while Derek goes on to state that he really is a doctor, the audible factor makes one of the more funny moments in a game? You know, play test the game? Overall, Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 is definitely a different game, offering up a gameplay format that most people have not tried, and one that most really don’t want to try. But, thanks to a proficient story, addictive and ever challenging gameplay, a constant, great theme, and a surprising soundtrack, the fifth surgery sim (Under the Knife, Second Opinion, New Blood, Under the Knife 2, and a dating sim with a surgery mini game (double parenthesis, yes I’m making fun of the latter game)) is definitely a great, original game that DS owners who can stomach the relatively mild content should try out. Issues are far and between, but unfortunately remain obvious enough to be accounted for. The Medical Board is harsh, man – they’re informed if you even fail to break a lock… Presentation, 9/10: The graphical interface has seen a major uplift, instructions are simple, and controls remain as solid as ever. A few changes and annoyances are found with the tools, unfortunately, marring the otherwise flawless new appearance. Graphics, 9/10: The new theme is a great new change to the game, making everything feel far more series and realistic. Effects have been greatly improved upon, organs look fairly realistic, and various wounds have all seen a graphical uplift. The occasional pixilation around object edges, as well as the occasional visual clutter and/or lack of definition are the only present, albeit minute, problems. Sound, 8/10: While the Trauma Center series continues to boast an amazing soundtrack, the various voice clips are really quite annoying, overused, and oftentimes mismatched to the tone of the current dialogue. Soundtracks remain excellent, though the post and pre-operation tunes don’t oftentimes match the current theme. Gameplay, 10/10: Now more accessible than ever, simulated surgery remains as addictive as ever, thanks to refined, challenging gameplay that, while staying the same, does just enough different to feel original without straying too far off the beaten path. Thanks also to a sharply written supporting story, a great overall theme, and several new operations, things remain as happening as ever. This is destined to be your next addiction. Replay Value, 8/10: Thanks to three difficulties, a plethora of operations and additional, unlockable operations, there is enough content to keep you playing for a long time to come. Unfortunately, unlocked missions are on a difficulty beyond hard, and the hard difficulty alone ensures that getting those highest ranks will be an extremely painful, time-consuming, and relatively pointless task. Total Score, 44/50: Atlus continues to surprise me, bringing yet another installment in the extremely odd and unpopulated medical simulator genre, and also bringing an excellent game to the table at the same time. A combination of some great visuals and music, a strong supporting story and gameplay that sucks you in makes for a really quite amazing game, but the staggering difficulty may turn away more casual players from this and pretty much every other Trauma Center game. Under the Knife 2 is the must have Trauma Center title, as well as a great game to be featured in any adventurous gamer's catalog. ...my word, things really have changed... And now, a notice from the actual reviewer - I've gained a bit of attention~! Granted, http://www.beefjack.com is currently a small site, but from the looks of it, it really could have the potential to grow into something more. But, as of this review, my content will be featured there (and possibly at GameFAQs, if the game itself is a newer release) for now on. I'll still be a patron to this site, however, so don't expect to see me vanish entirely from RomUlation, because I know you'd miss me if I just packed my bags and moved out when you were out golfing... ... I think.
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Interesting game, And very nice review. Look kinda awkward to be doing surgery on a DS...
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 It seems really wierd in theory, but the Wii versions of the game (Second Opinion, New Blood), when played right after this, feel especially loose and imprecise. The stylus controls are very sharp and make it a whole lot easier. When you first pick it up, you'll always be selecting the wrong tool or won't be doing things correctly, but once you've gotten a feel for the controls, it's hard to imagine the game any other way. Some people use two styli, which really scares me, and some people are actually good enough to beat the final boss (which is hard enough that I had to tone it down to easy to sanely beat) on the X difficulty, which is insanely, ridiculously difficult, and get the highest rank possible. Prepare for awesomeness and TEH UBER SPOILERS!!! This is the final boss, so if you don't want to know what it is, stray away...! But it's an awesome taste of the game at it's best, as well as some of the more imaginative GUILT displayed. So, anyways, brace for SPOILERS and AWESOMENESS: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QDlXW7Lnxwg ... I think he gets an XS on every single operation... I could never dream of being that good at a game XD
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Awesome review 9Ninebreaker9. This game is pretty good.
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Great review, I tried this game but I couldn't beat the boss, good game though, I'm hoping for a third. That video is...... amazing
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 great review as always. do you know what's a bummer about all of these reviews? nobody gets to really see them. the average views per review is close to 70, which is repeated because the creator of the review has to see it at least once, plus however many times there is a response to it. so if there are 10 comments on it, that's 11 views by the creator, then 10 more views by each person that commented. that's 21 views just from that, and usually the other 49 or so views are those same 10 people looking at it as well, whenever there is a response. so if you figure, there's really only 10-20 people actually looking at the reviews, who are normally regulars on the site. it has made me rethink of whether doing these reviews is worth it for the 10-20 people that see it.
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Yah your right about that. There are only a limited number of regulars on this forum and the chances are that only they'll look at it. I don't think many people join so they can write reviews, it's just a contest and thing for anyone inside or closely related to the game to follow.
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 it kinda defeats my purpose of writing reviews. i don't do it for contests, but just to have them written for people to reference to see if it is a good game or not, and whether it is worth buying, or renting, or whatever.
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 I played it o the wii, and I have to say that they used the wiis features good
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Whenever I do write a review, it does usually end up getting featured on GameFAQs, and several of them are also starred/recommended reviews with the TWEWY review having 10,000 hits, so I'm under the assumption that at least a few people do read it, and maybe my stuff has made people buy something or not buy something - I like writing them to just pass the time, as I would probably be clinically insane without a constant supply of stuffs to do. They did - between Second Opinion, Excite Truck and Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, I always liked the Trauma Center entry if only because of how how the controls were for the then brand new system. And the controls for it and New Blood definitely still hold up, but they just feel a little loose and imprecise when compared to the DS, which really isn't much of an issue, more so a note when I thought I'd own at the Wii titles and noticed a hUUUUge difference in not only the controls, but how each tool is used. Still though, I think my favorite has been New Blood - I like the story and the gameplay is fantastic. If you ever go looking for it, it's the game with the giant red cross on the cover <,<
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Never expected anything less from you And insanecrazy,that bug is bugging me
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 Hmm looks interesting ^^ thanks for the great review ^^
Re: [DS] Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2 - 9NineBreaker9 It's a great game but I got stuck at the end... Oh well
