I hope this registers as a good sig - please rate ...please be kind ....

i hope this qualifies as a nice to good sig

 

It's good, but the part that says "hot as fire" is a little hard to read. ;D


This type of post should actually go into the Signature Thread. Thanks!

https://www.romulation.org/forum/index.php/topic,4917.0.html

 

Honestly? 2/10, it looks like my cat accidentally ran across the keyboard when I had photoshop open.

The outer glow around "hot as fire' looks terrible, you cant even read the text, and the typeface has been destroyed, "cold as ice" isnt much better.

Thats curved text with your user name on it has completely warped the font, not to mention the bad placement.

The image is quite nice, even though its small, out of place and hasnt been added properly since I can see a white line to the left of it, probably the edge of the original image.

Finally the single colour plain black BG doesn't really say alot.

 

Almo is hilarious about his criticism. In honesty, though, this is far from aesthetically pleasing.

 

If this is your first time making a signature, I would rate it 8/10. Try using more brushes.

 

I like the shade of blue you used. I'd back the glow off of the "hot as ice" or try changing the glow color to the same shade of blue as the fire. Other than that it's a pretty awesome sig!

 

Kind of sucks xD
Seriously though, all Almo said is true, and he could've gone further, but he didn't. 3/10

 

Well to start - for me - there is to much text. Try sticking to one font for the whole thing. The image is good, i don't know if you made the fire effect of the reflection, but the black line through the reflection sorta catches my eye the most. Try and make some interesting backgrounds because black is sorta boring. One more thing, add a border, i see you've added one in your sig now. The border should contrast with the rest of your image.
Have a look at some tutorials, there is lots out there. I'm sure you can make some major improvements.

 

I give 6.79/10..
too dark..I can't see the text...the colour are not harmony..

 

its not bad you just need to improve i mean you're just starting from scrap for a beginner i'll say 10/10 but if you're an expert it could be better.